- CFA Exams
 - CFA Level I Exam
 - Topic 1. Quantitative Methods
 - Learning Module 4. Probability Trees and Conditional Expectations
 - Subject 3. Bayes' Formula and Updating Probability Estimates
 
CFA Practice Question
A mortgage holding company has found that 1% of its mortgage holders default on their mortgages and lose the property. Furthermore, 90% of those who default are late on at least two monthly payments over the life of their mortgage, as compared to 45% of those who do not default.
B. 0.018
C. 0.020
What is the probability that a mortgagee with two or more late monthly payments will default on the mortgage and lose the property?
A. 0.009
B. 0.018
C. 0.020
Correct Answer: C 
We have P(def) = 0.01. P(not def) = 0.99. P(two late payments/def) = 0.90. P(two late payments/not def) = 0.45. Using Bayes' formula: p(def/two late payments) = (0.01*0.9)/(0.01*0.9 + 0.99*0.45) = 0.0198 = 0.020
User Contributed Comments 8
| User | Comment | 
|---|---|
| Khadria | The answer is coming "0.0198" but if you round it to 3 decimal places then "D" is I N C O R R E C T | 
| bobert | Significant figures. If they are giving you those answers you generally round the furthest one by rule of thumb unless otherwise specified. | 
| epizi | Why will you prefer notation P(def) when it is said loss property when defaultie P(L/D). And that is the denominator: P(lose) Therefore P(Lose/Default)=1% P(lose/no Default)=99% P(Default)=90%  | 
    		
| epizi | P(No Default)=10% P(Lose)=P(Lose/Default)P(def)+P(Lose/noDef)P(no Def) =90%.1%+99%. 45%=0.4545 Bayee P(Def/Loss)=P(Loss/Def).P(Def)/P(lose) =(0.01x0.90)/0.4545=0.020  | 
    		
| Beret | Forget about all the formulas like Bayes etc. Just draw a tree diagram to solve all these kind of problems. It works! | 
| raymondg | could somebody please work out probability tree thanks | 
    		
| farhan92 | @Raymond  Probability of Default 1%. Prob of not default = 99% Prob Default and Late =0.9, Prob Def and not late =0.1 Prob non def and late =0,45 so Prob def and late =0.55.  | 
    		
| ecapocas | Tried it both ways. Tree is definitely easier and better. For me anyway, YMMV. |