Financial Reporting and Analysis III
Reading 27. Income Taxes
Learning Outcome Statements
b. explain how deferred tax liabilities and assets are created and the factors that determine how a company's deferred tax liabilities and assets should be treated for the purposes of financial analysis;
d. calculate income tax expense, income taxes payable, deferred tax assets, and deferred tax liabilities, and calculate and interpret the adjustment to the financial statements related to a change in the income tax rate;
CFA Curriculum, 2020, Volume 3
Subject 2. Deferred Tax Assets and Liabilities
In the U.S.:
- Tax reporting is based on the Internal Revenue Code (the tax code).
- The modified cash basis of accounting is used in tax reporting to determine the periodic liability from currently taxable events.
- Revenue and expense recognition methods used in tax reporting often differ from those used in financial reporting.
- Financial reporting is based on GAAP.
- Accrual accounting is used in financial reporting to provide maximum information to allow evaluation of a firm's financial performance and cash flows.
- Management is allowed to select revenue and expense recognition methods. A firm has a strong incentive to use methods that allow it to minimize taxable income.
Because of the differences between tax accounting and financial accounting, the financial statements may include tax liabilities or assets - allowances that have been made in the financial statements for taxes that have not yet been or have already been paid.
Deferred tax liabilities generally arise when tax relief is provided in advance of an accounting expense, or when income is accrued but not taxed until received. Deferred tax liabilities on an individual transaction are expected to be reversed when these liabilities are settled, causing future cash outflows.
A typical example is depreciation: a company uses the Accelerated Cost Recovery System for tax reporting but uses straight-line depreciation for financial reporting.
- Recall that taxes payable is calculated based on taxable income, and tax expense is calculated based on accounting profit.
- Lower depreciation expense in financial reporting results in accounting profit that is higher than taxable income, and tax expense that is higher than taxes payable.
- Deferred tax liabilities are thus created.
Deferred tax assets generally arise when tax relief is provided after an expense is deducted for accounting purposes. Deferred tax assets on an individual transaction are expected to be reversed when these assets are recovered, causing future cash inflows. Different treatments of warranty expenses in tax reporting and financial reporting are a common cause of deferred tax assets:
- For tax reporting, warranty expenses cannot be recognized until they have been incurred. For financial reporting, warranty expenses are recognized each year using accrual accounting, regardless of whether they are incurred or not.
- Lower warranty expense in tax reporting results in taxable income that is higher than accounting profit, and tax payable that is higher than tax expense.
- Deferred tax assets are thus created.
In the U.S., deferred tax assets/liabilities are classified on the balance sheet as current or non-current based on the classification of the underlying asset or liability. However, deferred tax assets/liabilities are always classified as non-current under IFRS.
A deferred tax item cannot be created if it is doubtful that the company will realize economic benefits in the future.
A company purchases an asset for $1,000 at the beginning of Year 1. It depreciates the asset at 33% per annum (straight-line) for financial reporting. The tax depreciation is 50% per annum (straight-line). The pretax income and taxable income are $2,000 before depreciation for Year 1 to 3. Assume a tax rate of 30%.
The company will report the following for tax reporting:
Taxes payable is based on taxable income, not accounting profit.
Taxes payable = Taxable income x Tax rate
The company will report the following for financial reporting:
The deferred taxation can be computed in two ways:
- (Taxable income - accounting profit) x tax rate
- (Tax base - carrying amount) x tax rate
Take Year 1 as an example:
- (Taxable income - accounting profit) x tax rate = (1,500 - 1667) x 30% = -50
- (Tax base - carrying amount) x tax rate = (500 - 667) x 30% = -50
The textbook uses the second approach to calculate deferred tax assets/liabilities. At the end of each year, these are calculated by comparing the tax base and carrying amounts of the balance sheet items.
Note that tax expense can be broken down into taxes payable and deferred taxation.
- Year 1: taxes payable (450) + deferred tax liabilities (50) = Tax expense (500)
- Year 2: taxes payable (450) + deferred tax liabilities (50) = Tax expense (500)
- Year 3: taxes payable (600) + deferred tax liabilities (-100) = Tax expense (500)
In Year 1 and 2 the deferred tax is a liability in the balance sheet and an additional expense in the income statement. This occurs because the tax depreciation (500) is greater than the accounting depreciation charge (333). If the situation had been the other way around, a deferred tax asset would have resulted. This is the case when the pretax accounting profit is less than the taxable income.
In Year 3 the deferred tax is a reversal of the deferred tax liability on the balance sheet and a saving in the income statement. This occurs because the tax depreciation (0) is less than the depreciation charge for financial reporting (334).
As can be seen above, at the end of the three years there is no deferred tax on the balance sheet. This is why it is referred to as a temporary difference. The total tax (1,500) and total net income (3,500) are the same for tax and financial reporting. It is just the timing of their recognition that is different. At the end of the day, the tax collector and the accountant arrive at the same result.
Here are some important "tricks" you will need to know well for the exams.
A common question on the exam asks you to compute taxes payable or the tax expense. You may be given the pretax income, but need the taxable income figure to compute taxes payable. To adjust pretax income to taxable income and vice versa when assets have different depreciable lives for tax and accounting, remember the following:
- Pretax income + Accounting depreciation - Tax depreciation = Taxable Income, or
- Taxable Income + Tax depreciation - Accounting depreciation = Pretax Income, or
- Taxable Income + Temporary differences creating deferred tax liabilities - Temporary differences creating deferred tax assets = Pretax Income
Once you have determined the pretax income or taxable income, you can determine the taxes payable and tax expense as follows:
- Pretax income x tax rate = tax expense in the income statement
- Taxable income x tax rate = taxes payable
- Taxes payable + deferred tax effect on income statement = tax expense in the income statement
User Contributed Comments 11You need to log in first to add your comment.
Deferrred tax liability- future taxable income > future pretax income Deferred tax asset - future pretax income > future taxable income
The White Text on p430 conflicts itself:
Deferred Tax Liabilities arise when future taxable income is expected to exceed pre-tax income.....
But then he changes his mind at the bottom of the page stating a Deferred Tax Liability generated when "Pre-tax income exceeds Taxable Income"
Could someone please clarify what is correct? Are they both confused or am I???
I usually picture deferred tax liability as additional taxes to be paid in the future. This can be possible if we are paying less now, ie taxable income is less than pre-tax income.
The opposite occurs when you look at the deferred tax assets: there are less taxes to pay in the future because current taxable income is higher than pre-tax income.
The temporary differences between taxable income and pre-tax income reverse in the future, ie at the end, in total, you pay the same amount of taxes.
Hope this helps.
As "Impairments recognized for financial reporting are not deductible for tax purposed until the affected assets are disposed of", impairments that are deducted for financial reporting but not yet deducted for tax purposes lead to:
1. Lower depreciation expense for financial reporting and higher for tax purpose
2. Higher earnings for financial reporting and lower for tax purposes
3. Consequently higher tax will be reported on the financial statement but actually pay less
Therefore Deferred Tax Asset (DTA) holds.
After the affected assets are actually disposed of, the depreciation expense and net income for both tax purposes and reporting becomes identical. No DTA appears.
Is that correct?
I assume you are at level 1 and using the 3rd ed of the White text cos my 2nd ed text is phrased a little different. Your 3rd ed text stating that a DTL is generated when "Pretax Income exceeds Taxable Income' at the paragraph end (ie bottom of the page) is CORRECT and is consistent with the earlier phrase that "DTL arise when future taxable income is expected to exceed pre-tax income...."
When pre-tax income exceeds taxable income [due to temporary differences arising from the different depreciation methods applied under financial reporting (usually straight line method) and tax return (usually accelerated method)], the current tax expense computed and recorded under financial reporting will exceed the current tax payable (computed under tax-return) amount. The excess amount, although not payable at the current moment, is payable when the temporary difference reverses in the future (at which then the taxable income will exceed pre-tax income) and therefore represents a Liability which has been Deferred to a later date, hence the term Deferred Tax Liability (DTL).
For info, you would be right to be confused if you were using the earlier 2nd ed. Incidently the paragraph ending text in the 2nd ed (also pg 430) was errorneous as it phrased "Differences between financial accounting and tax accounting can also give rise to deferred tax assets when future pretax income is expected to be less than taxable income." It should have been '... expected to be MORE than taxable income.' Good thing that the error has been corrected in the 3rd ed. I hope this helps to clarify your thoughts.
hey tony1973...u confuse me..now....
"differences between financial accounting and tax accounting can also give rise to deferred tax assets when future pretax income is expected to be less than taxable income." It should have been '... expected to be MORE than taxable income.'
u create a DTL when pre-tax income (from financial) is higher than taxable income
u create a DTA when pre-tax income (from financial reporting) is lower than taxable income.
is that right...???
Yup! You are right that:
u create a DTL when pre-tax income (from financial) is higher than taxable income
u create a DTA when pre-tax income (from financial reporting ) is lower than taxable income.
PROVIDED that you are comparing between the incomes at PRESENT.
I guess what is most confusing about the errorneous sentence in the 2nd ed White text is their reference to FUTURE pretax income vs FUTURE taxable income when DTA (which was highlighted in italics in the 2nd ed text) is generated at present. I guess the authors realized the sentence was awkward as it implicitly assumes the reversal of the temporary difference in the FUTURE (which we know is not always the case - L2 stuff here). As future reversals are not guaranteed events, I guess the authors decided to correct the error by referencing the situation to the PRESENT and using DTL (instead of DTA) in the 3rd ed.
Maybe the 'formula' (applicable to the PRESENT) should help:
Tax Expense (FR) = Tax payable (TR) + DTL - DTA
FR: Financial Reporting
TR: Tax Return
Hope this helps!
Can anyone explain a deferred tax liability created from and liability (not an asset)? There are plenty of examples of a DTA and DTL for an asset and there are examples of DTA's for a liability but I cant find a Liability DTL anywhere. Anyone can explain?
in case a company has doubts regarding economic benefits in the future whilst having tax assets items in B/S:
IFRS: reversal is created
GAAP: valuation allowance is established
This section is more confusing than Brexit