- CFA Exams
- Level I 2020
- Study Session 9. Financial Reporting and Analysis (4)
- Reading 29. Financial Reporting Quality
- Subject 4. Detection of Financial Reporting Quality Issues
Subject 4. Detection of Financial Reporting Quality Issues PDF Download
There is really nothing new in this reading, just a review of the previous material. A lot of the accounting practices are highlighted elsewhere in the curriculum but are reiterated here.
If a company uses a non-GAAP financial measure in an SEC filing, it is required to provide the most directly comparable GAAP measure with equivalent prominence in the filing. In addition, the company is required to provide a reconciliation between the non-GAAP measure and the equivalent GAAP measure.
Similarly, IFRS require that any non-IFRS measures included in financial reports must be defined and their potential relevance explained. The non-IFRS measures must be reconciled with IFRS measures.
Accounting Choices and Estimates
Managers' considerable flexibility in choosing their companies' accounting policies and formulating estimates provides opportunities for aggressive accounting.
- Revenue recognition policies.
- Inventory cost flow assumptions.
- Capitalization policies.
- Estimates of uncollectible account receivable.
- Estimated realizability of deferred tax assets.
- Depreciation method, estimated salvage value of depreciable assets, and estimated useful life of depreciable assets.
Cash flow, especially operating cash flow and free cash flow, are always at the heart of any discussion of financial performance and valuation. Investors, creditors, and analysts are all interested in whether a firm is generating cash flow and where that cash flow can be expected to recur.
Operating cash flow is usually unaffected by estimates and judgments. However, firms can still create the perception that sustainable operating cash flow is greater than it actually is. One technique is to misrepresent a firm's cash-generating ability by classifying financing activities as operating activities and vice versa. Additionally, management has discretion over the timing of cash flows and where to report cash flows.
Analysts should pay attention to:
- Revenue. Check revenue recognition policies and revenue relationship.
- Inventories. Look at inventory relationships.
- Capitalization policies and deferred costs.
- The relationship of cash flow and net income.
- Other warning signs.
Learning Outcome Statementsg. describe presentation choices, including non-GAAP measures, that could be used to influence an analyst's opinion;
h. describe accounting methods (choices and estimates) that could be used to manage earnings, cash flow, and balance sheet items;
i. describe accounting warning signs and methods for detecting manipulation of information in financial reports.
CFA® Level I Curriculum, 2020, Volume 3, Reading 29
User Contributed Comments 7
|ndepierre||Special Purpose Entities|
|weldie||How can excessive use of operating lease is a sign?|
|czar||"operating" lease is off-balance sheet....this shows better (lower) debt to equity ratios - which makes the company look good....it also shows better (higher) asset turnover ratios|
|moneyguy||good answer, czar!|
|bidisha||How LIFO liquidations|
|benmingo||still dont get what trade relief is|
I am using your study notes and I know of at least 5 other friends of mine who used it and passed the exam last Dec. Keep up your great work!
My Own Flashcard
No flashcard found. Add a private flashcard for the subject.