Reading 49. Basics of Derivative Pricing and Valuation
Learning Outcome Statements
a. explain how the concepts of arbitrage, replication, and risk neutrality are used in pricing derivatives;
CFA Curriculum, 2020, Volume 6
Why should I choose AnalystNotes?
AnalystNotes specializes in helping candidates pass. Period.
Subject 1. The Principle of Arbitrage
Arbitrage and Derivatives
Assume the risk-free rate is 5%. The current price of gold is $300 per ounce and the forward price of gold is $330 in one year's time. Is there an arbitrage opportunity?
Here is what you can do:
- Borrow $300 at 5% today.
- Buy one ounce of gold (price $300).
- Enter into a short forward to sell one ounce of gold for $330 in one year's time.
- After one year you sell the gold for $330, and repay the bank $300 plus $15 interest.
Hence, a profit of $15 can be made without any risk!
In fact, any delivery price above $315 will result in a risk-free profit using this strategy.
What if the delivery price is $310?
- Sell one ounce of gold for $300.
- Deposit the $300 in the bank at 5% interest.
- Enter into a forward to buy one ounce of gold in one year's time for the delivery price ($310).
- After one year, buy one ounce of gold for $310 and keep the $5 profit.
Again, a profit of $5 can be made without any risk.
Investors in the gold market will take advantage of any forward price that is not equal to $315, eventually bring the price to $315, which is known as the arbitrage-free price.
The arbitrage principle is the essence of derivative pricing models.
Arbitrage and Replication
A portfolio composed of the underlying asset and the riskless asset could be constructed to have exactly the same cash flows as a derivative. This portfolio is called the replicating portfolio. Since they have the same cash flows, they would have to sell at the same price (the law of one price).
Assume the forward price of gold is $315 in one year's time, and the spot price is $300. You have $300.
- You can deposit $300 in the bank at 5% interest. One year later you will get $315.
- You can also buy one ounce of gold, and a forward contract to sell it in one year for $315. One year later you will also get $315.
- To explore pricing differentials
- Lower transaction costs
Replication is the essence of arbitrage.
Risk Aversion, Risk Neutrality, and Arbitrage-Free Pricing
Risk-seeking investors give away a risk premium because they enjoy taking risk. Risk-averse investors expect a risk premium to compensate for the risk. Risk-neutral investors neither give nor receive a risk premium because they have no feelings about risk.
Risk-neutral pricing: Suppose you want to price a derivative. The payoff of this derivate can be replicated using the underlying asset and risk-free rate. The market price of this derivative and the replicating strategy must be exactly the same under the principle of no arbitrage, regardless of risk preferences.
To obtain the derivative price we should assume the investor is risk-neutral, because an investor's risk aversion is not a factor in determining the derivative price. Risk can be eliminated by dynamic hedging in a situation where there is no arbitrage possible. Once risk is eliminated in this way the expected return becomes equal to the risk-free rate for all investors. Assets can be assumed to grow at the risk-free rate and also discounted at the risk-free rate.
User Contributed Comments 1You need to log in first to add your comment.
You want to price a derivative on gold, a gold certificate. The product just pays the current price of an ounce in $.
Now, how would you price it? Would you think about your risk preferences? No, you won't, you would just take the current gold price and perhaps add some spread. Therefore the risk preferences did not matter (=risk neutrality) because this product is derived (= derivative) from an underlying product (=underlying).
This is because all of the different risk preferences of the market participants is already included in the price of the underlying and the derivative can be hedged with the underlying continuously (at least this is what is often taken for granted). As soon as the price of the gold certificate diverges from the original price a shrewd trader would just buy/sell the underlying and sell/buy the certificate to pocket a risk free profit - and the price will soon come back again...
So, you see, the basic concept of risk neutrality is quite natural and easy to grasp. Of course, the devil is in the details... but that is another story.